Does antigone deserve to be punished
Antigone worksheets answers prologue 1 what information does antigone give to ismene at the beginning of this scene creon has declared that anyone who buries polynieces will be stoned to death 2 the criminal must be punished 2 in lines 37-44, what feelings does antigone express about her father. Does shylock deserve his punishment shylock is punished by the venetian court for seeking to end antonio’s life he is charged under a venetian law (of shakespeare’s creation) and he is forced to give up his wealth and to beg the duke to spare him his life. In antigone creon tried to impose a cruel and unusual punishment on antigone by locking her in a stone cave until she died this had him lose a lot of support and be punished in the end maybe the writers of the constitution read antigone and learned from his mistake. Antigone's outrage that proper burial has been denied to one of her brothers shows that she does not use the same standard for her, loyalty to family is more important than polynices's disloyalty to thebes.
Rather than follow ismene’s cowardly example of passive acceptance or cringe before creon’s wrathful intimidation, antigone does her moral duty to her brother, defies creon’s unreasonable law, and suffers the consequences of disobedience—imprisonment and death. Earlier in the play, the chorus was firmly on creon’s side and agreed that the criminal must be punished in lines 37-44, what feelings does antigone express about her father she believes that her father’s crimes have infected the family and that her misfortunes are linked to the curse of his actions. The first thing creon does in antigone is declare a harsh but understandable law he proclaims that while the body of eteocles will be buried with dignity, the corpse of polyneices will be left to rot on the field of battle anyone who attempts to honor polyneices's body with burial will be sentenced to death.
Scenes 2 and 3 scene 2: the sentry returns with antigone who returned to the site of her crime to rebury her brother after the layer of dirt had been removedantigone readily admits the crime an argument ensues with antigone claiming she was merely obeying the laws of the gods and that creon will be punished. One then feels as though they deserve to be punished and this shows they are indentified with how they feel, and being punished by others (or themselves) is going to be what feels comfortable other people can then wonder why they are putting up with bad behaviour, for instance, but it might not even stand out to them. Oedipus calls tiresias, the blind prophet, to help him in his quest, but when the old man refuses to reveal the painful truth to oedipus, the king becomes angered, causing tiresias to say that it is oedipus himself who pollutes the city and is the murderer of laius. Xiaoqing shi dr - antigone's justification essay introduction henry bayerle classics 102q 25 november 2011 does antigone deserve to be punished henry bayerle classics 102q 25 november 2011 does antigone deserve to be punished.
Death 2: the punishment for burying polyneices' body is death by public stoning ismene is afraid that her sister antigone will die too if she buries polyneices against the wishes of creon she does not want to be the only person in her entire family who is left alive, so she begs antigone not to violate creon's decree. Both of antigone and creon stick to their ideas, but i think i am more on antigone's side although polyneices was unwise to join enemy country, the punishment for him is too severe the law was not such a proper one. Antigone was not the only character of the play with a fate that she lived up to for example, creon is destined to be alone after his decisions lead to the deaths of almost everyone around him he ignores the consequences of his actions at first and attempts to correct his mistakes but not until it is too late. No, oedipus does not deserve the punishment that he receives in oedipus rex by sophocles (495 bce - 405 bce) specifically, theban king oedipus will be executed or exiled for killing his.
Does antigone deserve to be punished
In the play “antigone”, sophocles at first portrays creon as a just leaderhe has good, rational reasons for his laws and punishments by the end of the play creon’s hubris, or excessive pride, has taken over him, which leads to his demise. If someone took an action that harmed others, including many others, i want to shift from thinking that they now deserve punishment, or would better be dead i want, instead,. Ismene is, at first, unwilling to help antigone bury polyneices because ismene a thinks that creon is right to forbid his burial b does not want to be punished for breaking the law. A) in my opinion, antigone, while she deserves to be honored, must also suffer the consequences it really depends on the view of the reader, whether they believe in the rights of the king, or whether they are more humane.
The positions of antigone and creon are opposed, but both posses the same stubborn belief in their own righteousness on the issue of the burial one is right, and one is wrong, but both share the blame for the tragic end of the play. Transcript of antigone quotable quotes antigone quotable quotes by: panhia vang, noah tiegs, and gabbie gervais we learn that the dead deserve respect if you die, make sure you've impacted someone enough that they will bury you big words are always punished, and proud men in old age learn to be wise these are the last lines spoken.
A summary of antigone, lines 701–1090 in sophocles's the oedipus plays creon pleased, the king praises his son’s wisdom haemon reports that he has heard it said among the people that antigone does not deserve such punishment for her noble-seeming deed he implores his father not to be so sure of his rightness the last son of the. Antigone (/ æ n ˈ t ɪ ɡ ə n i / ann-tig-ə-nee ancient greek: ἀντιγόνη) is a tragedy by sophocles written in or before 441 bc of the three theban plays antigone is the third in order of the events depicted in the plays, but it is the first that was written the play expands on the theban legend that predates it, and it picks up where aeschylus' seven against thebes ends. Antigone feels that her self-imposed task is worth dying for, and would bring her glory, making her death noble despite it being a punishment antigone’s anger, in addition to being caused by the idea of not honoring her brother’s death, could also be because she felt that creon’s orders were directly meant to harm her and her sister. Antigone does what is ethical by pursuing what would be right in accordance to the gods, not in accordance to creon creon believed that polyneices did not deserve to be buried before antigone is sent to dies, she tells creon, “you will remember / what things i suffer, and at what’s men’s hands / because i would not transgress the laws.